Cherry Chip Cake Mix refers to a once-popular boxed cake mix from Betty Crocker that baked up into a sweet, pink cherry-flavored cake. It was famous for its subtle maraschino-cherry taste, pale pink crumb, and tiny red “cherry chips” scattered throughout the cake. For decades it was a go-to mix for birthdays and holidays – one food writer says it even “earned its cult following” among nostalgic bakers. This boxed mix was part of Betty Crocker’s Super Moist line, meaning the mix already contained pudding for extra moisture and only needed eggs, water, and oil to bake. In short, Cherry Chip Cake Mix is a flavored cake mix (by Betty Crocker) that produces a pink, cherry-studded cake with a sweet maraschino taste. Unfortunately, the original boxed mix has been discontinued, which is why many fans now look for ways to recreate the cake at home.
A Nostalgic Cherry-Flavored Cake
If you grew up in the 80s or 90s, chances are you remember Betty Crocker’s Cherry Chip Cake Mix. It baked into a bright pink cake dotted with little red “cherry chips” (artificial cherry bits) and filled the kitchen with a sweet cherry aroma. The flavor was often compared to cherry-speckled ice cream or maraschino cherries in cake form. As one blogger noted, the mix “produced a cherry-flavored cake filled with cherry-flavored chips scattered throughout” – the kind that made licking the spoon irresistible. It really stood out between classics like Funfetti and Super Moist Chocolate on the shelf. In fact, Blue’s Best Life magazine describes it as a “nostalgic flavor that won’t stay on shelves,” thanks to its subtle cherry taste and festive pink color. Because it was part of the Super Moist series, baking it was easy – just add water, oil, and eggs (or butter) and bake, and you’d end up with a moist cherry cake that kids loved.
Why It’s Hard to Find
By the mid-2020s, Betty Crocker’s Cherry Chip mix had become nearly impossible to find. Fans took to online forums and social media sharing frustration over empty shelves and pay-to-play resellers. Many shoppers report that stores simply don’t stock it anymore. Even when it briefly returned as a limited summer release in 2025, supply was scarce. Betty Crocker’s own Instagram hinted at a summer 2025 restock, but that supply “was so high that fans cleaned out the stock,” leaving many still searching. As one reporter put it, Cherry Chip Cake Mix “has had a complicated history” – technically it returned in summer 2025, but distribution was “limited and uneven,” meaning some regions saw it while others didn’t. In fact, a company statement in 2025 admitted the mix would be seasonal, and by early 2026 even online sites like Walmart had none listed. In short, nostalgia-led demand has outstripped supply. Fans are still holding out hope for a permanent comeback, but for now the easiest way to enjoy this cake is to bake it yourself.
DIY Cherry Chip Cake (Homemade Alternatives)
Since the boxed mix is rare, many home bakers improvise their own versions. The general strategy is to start with a simple vanilla or white cake base and add cherries for flavor and color. Here are some popular approaches:
-
White Cake Mix Hack: Use a basic white or yellow box cake mix as your base. Then stir in the juice from a jar of maraschino cherries and the chopped cherries themselves. This “doctored” mix will bake into the same pink-tinged cherry cake that the old mix produced. (One food blog even calls vanilla-plus-maraschino flavor the “model” to mimic.)
-
From-Scratch Cherry Cake: For a more homemade approach, bake a cake from scratch by creaming butter and sugar, then adding eggs, flour, etc., and folding in lots of chopped maraschinos (or fresh sweet cherries) at the end. Food52’s Homemade Cherry Chip Cake recipe follows this method: it replaces the artificial cherry chips with real maraschino cherries, and even tops the cake with vanilla buttercream and fresh cherries. Bakers love this route because it yields a cake “better than boxed” and feels more natural.
-
Angel Food Cake Version: Another idea is to make an old-school angel food cake (or any light white cake) and gently fold in chopped maraschinos or maraschino cherry juice. The Takeout suggests this as a way to capture that bright cherry flavor in a fluffy cake base.
-
Flavor and Color Boosters: To truly nail the taste, many add a hint of almond extract – it pairs perfectly with cherries and gives an extra nod to cherry desserts. Also, using bright red (often dyed) maraschino cherries can help your cake look just like the original. (Some even buy neon-red cherries or premium brands like Luxardo or Fabbri for more natural color and flavor.)
These DIY tricks will help you recreate that classic cherry chip taste. Some bakers even use the batter to make cupcakes instead of a full cake – just reduce baking time (about 15 minutes) and you have cherry-flecked cupcakes. The key is lots of cherry juice and cherry pieces in the batter. As one blogger puts it, the pink “chips” in the old mix were basically imitation – real cherries deliver a brighter taste.
Serving Tips and Variations
Once your cherry cake is baked, you can serve it in classic style. Traditionally, Cherry Chip Cake was frosted simply with white or vanilla icing and crowned with more cherries. For example, Food52’s cake ends up with a light vanilla buttercream and real cherries as garnish. You could also try a whipped cream topping and a cherry on each slice for a retro look. These touches make your homemade cake look like the vintage original.
Other fun variations: turn it into cherry chip cupcakes by spooning batter into muffin tins – just watch closely and bake for about 15 minutes to avoid overbaking. Or layer slices with whipped cream and cherry jam to make a trifle or parfait. The important thing is to celebrate the cherry flavor. One hack from fan forums: if your cake turns out too pink, rinse and pat dry the maraschinos before mixing them in to keep the cake crumb more yellow.
Above all, enjoy the nostalgia. Whether you’re cutting a tall layer cake or a batch of cupcakes, topping with bright red cherries and creamy frosting, the end result should taste like a walk down memory lane. Even if the boxed mix is gone, these homemade methods let you bake the cherry chip cake of your youth in your own kitchen.
Final Thoughts
Cherry Chip Cake Mix may be hard to buy today, but its legacy lives on in kitchens everywhere. By understanding what made the original mix special – its unique cherry flavor and pink hue – you can recreate a very similar dessert yourself. Start with a trusty white cake recipe or mix, load it up with maraschino cherry juice and chopped cherries, and frost it simply. Those who remember the old boxed cake will smile at the first bite. With a little DIY spirit, the cherished Cherry Chip flavor can still be the centerpiece of your next celebration.
